Our Cupcake Menu

Velvets & Classics

$2.95 each | $31.00 a dozen

Red Velvet

On Oprah's “O” list! Mild chocolate cake in a rich red, topped with sweet cream cheese frosting. Enjoyed by Barbara Walters & friends on The View.

Blue Velvet

One of "Oprah's Favorite Things!" Moist "blue" vanilla cake topped with our cream cheese frosting, sprinkles & silver balls.

Classic Vanilla with Pastel

Vanilla cake, topped with our delicious pastel buttercream & a sugar flower. Available in a variety of pastel colors.

Classic Vanilla with Fudge

Vanilla cake, topped with delicious chocolate fudge icing & a sugar flower.

Classic Chocolate with Pastel

Chocolate cake, topped with our pastel buttercream & a sugar flower. Available in a variety of pastel colors.

Classic Chocolate with Fudge

Chocolate cake, topped with rich chocolate fudge & a sugar flower.

Signature Cupcakes

$2.95 each | $31.00 a dozen

Blackout

Chocolate cake, topped with a creamy, dark chocolate pudding, covered in moist chocolate cake crumbs.

Carrot

Carrot cake, topped with our famous sweet cream cheese icing, surrounded by toasted coconut flakes.

Cookie Dough

Vanilla cake, topped with a scoop of cookie dough, (raw and eggless), large chunks of homemade blondies, and finished off with a chocolate drizzle.

M&M Vanilla

Vanilla cake, topped with our buttercream, then dipped into a rainbow of miniature M&M's.

M&M Chocolate

Chocolate cake, topped with our buttercream, then dipped into a rainbow of miniature M&M's.

Snickers

Vanilla cake with buttercream icing, dipped into chunks of Snicker pieces.

Tie Dye

Vanilla cake iced with a swirl of buttercream, airbrushed with bright tie dye colors & topped off with a sugar peace sign.

Brownie

Chocolate cake, topped with chocolate fudge icing & yummy brownie chunks, drizzled with milk & white chocolate sauce.

Chip

Chocolate cake with chocolate fudge icing surrounded by chocolate sprinkles & topped off with chocolate chips.

Dirt & Worm

Chocolate cake, topped with chocolate fudge, dipped in Oreo crumbs, with a gummy worm on top.

Oreo

Chocolate cake iced with Oreo buttercream & dipped in chunks of crushed Oreo bits.

Strawberry

Vanilla cake, topped with strawberry buttercream, finished with pink chocolate curl.

Cannoli

Vanilla cake, topped with our Italian style cannoli cheese icing surrounded by crushed cannoli shells & miniature chocolate chips.

Chocolate Cheese

Chocolate cake iced with our famous sweetened cream cheese frosting and topped with chocolate chips.

Fondant

Vanilla cake, topped with white fondant surrounded by multi-colored nonpareils.

Mocha

Vanilla or Chocolate cake topped with a mocha flavored buttercream and a chocolate covered mocha bean.

Turtle

Vanilla cake, topped with our cream cheese icing, surrounded by crushed pecans and a caramel & chocolate drizzle.

Infused Cupcakes

$2.95 each | $31.00 a dozen

Apple Pie

Vanilla cake filled with an apple compote, topped with sweet cinnamon cream cheese frosting, caramel drizzle & apple pie crumbs.

Banana Split

Vanilla cake filled with strawberry banana custard, topped with vanilla buttercream, chocolate syrup & rainbow sprinkles.

Coconut Lemon

Vanilla cake, filled with lemon custard, topped with our sunny lemon buttercream, surrounded by sweetened coconut flakes.

Key Lime

Vanilla cake, infused with key lime pie filling, topped with a key lime flavored buttercream & sprinkled with candied lime zest.

Pink Snowball

Chocolate cake, filled & topped with marshmallow fluff buttercream, dipped in pink coconut.

Snowball

Vanilla cake, filled with coconut crème filing, topped with vanilla buttercream, dipped in sweetened coconut flakes.

Boston Cream

Vanilla cake, infused with homemade custard, topped with chocolate fudge & a dollop of custard.

Memphis

An Oprah favorite! Vanilla cake, filled with banana custard, topped with peanut butter buttercream, chocolate ganache & peanut butter drizzle.

Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate cake filled with peanut butter buttercream, with fudge, Reese’s peanut butter cup chunks, and peanut butter & chocolate drizzle.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Vanilla cake filled with strawberry preserves, topped with cream cheese frosting, graham cracker crumble & strawberry drizzle.

Chocolate Raspberry

Chocolate cake, filled with raspberry jam, topped with chocolate fudge & raspberry swirls and chocolate cake crumbs.

Hostess

Chocolate cake, filled & topped with our buttercream, dipped in a rich chocolate ganache, finished with a Hostess inspired swirl.

Salty Caramel

Vanilla or chocolate cake, filled & topped with a salted caramel buttercream, a caramel drizzle & a sprinkle of sea salt.

Mousse

Chocolate cake, filled & topped with our famous chocolate mousse, finished with a drizzle of chocolate ganache.

Napoleon

Vanilla cake, filled with our homemade custard, topped with chocolate swirled fondant, surrounded by puff pastry flakes.

S'mores

Vanilla cake filled with fluff buttercream, topped with chocolate ganache, marshmallow fluff, graham crackers & chocolate sauce.

Babycakes

$13.95 a dozen (pre-packaged)

Babycake Assortment

Twelve bite-sized gourmet cupcakes! 2 Red Velvet, 2 Blue Velvet, 2 Classics, 2 Snowball, 2 Oreo, 2 Chip.

Vegan and Gluten Free

Contact stores for pricing.

Vegan and Gluten Free Cupcakes

There's a scrumptious assortment of Vegan and Gluten Free cupcakes available in our Ridgewood & Englewood cupcake shops. Baked by By the Way Bakery. Plus, they're Kosher! Contact us for more details.